Repository logo
  • Log In
    New user? Click here to register.Have you forgotten your password?
University College Dublin
    Colleges & Schools
    Statistics
    All of DSpace
  • Log In
    New user? Click here to register.Have you forgotten your password?
  1. Home
  2. College of Social Sciences and Law
  3. School of Geography
  4. Geography Research Collection
  5. 'Insiders', 'Outsiders', and the Geography of Regional Life
 
  • Details
Options

'Insiders', 'Outsiders', and the Geography of Regional Life

Author(s)
Buttimer, Anne  
Uri
http://hdl.handle.net/10197/10729
Date Issued
1979
Date Available
2019-05-30T10:27:52Z
Abstract
Two distinct connotations of term ‘region’ have generated two distinct and often separate fields of endeavour within geography. Traditional regional geography has focused on the description of areally-circumscribed territories, while regional science (in the Anglo-American world) has tended to be more analytical and more specifically concerned with nodally-organized functional regions. Two contrasting definitions of space and time are implicit here – the former derives from a Newtonian notion of space and time as containers of objects while the latter derives from a relational notion of space-time as topological surface. For a number of sociological and ideological reasons, however, both share a perspective on knowledge and experience which could be regarded as an ‘outsider’ one. The ‘insider’s’ perspective has not received much explicit attention, largely because of difficulties in generalization and a fear of ‘subjectivism’. Arguments are raised to support the view that the geographer’s task is the articulation of neither inside nor outsider views exclusively but rather to confront the challenge of the dialectic between the two within concrete life situations.

From a philosophical viewpoint it could be argued that objectivity demands a critical sensitivity to the logic and appropriateness of models used in research. To take any descriptive model which has appeared for particular settings and then apply it indiscriminately to other settings is one example of cultural ‘subjectivism’ e.g. the kind of regional geography which became a mouthpiece for national/ colonial/ class interests. On a logical plane, also, regional-science models appropriate for particular realms, yet there have been many gaucheries of spatial blueprinting in realms as different as industrial, educational and health planning. It is at the practical level of everyday life, however, that the juxtaposition of these two types of regionalization often creates most confusion. On philosophical, logical, and practical grounds, it could be argued that no long-term solution can be reached without involving the ‘insider’, viz. those whose lives are affected by changes in regional organization and administration. Until better communication between managerial and resident interest can be attained, geography cannot claim either relevance or truth.

The most urgent task for the regional geographer thus becomes one of education in the literal sense: to evoke an awareness of the values implicit in his own a priori presuppositions and then to facilitate an awareness of environment and responsibility among the audience of his work. This paper shares some insights derived from various attempts to apply this perspective in both teaching and research and also points to avenues for joint exploration by scholars attained to either ‘insider’ or ‘outsider’ stances on regional life. It concludes with a challenge, old and new, of seeking a common language which might contribute toward a harmonization of the currently diverse and fragmented strands of thought and practice within regional geography.
Type of Material
Book Chapter
Publisher
Finnpublishers
Start Page
155
End Page
178
Subjects

Time and space

Cultural subjectivism...

Regional geography

Regional geographer

Language
English
Status of Item
Peer reviewed
Journal
Kuklinski, A., Kultalahti, O., Koskiaho, B. (eds.). Regional Dynamics of Socio-Economic Change
This item is made available under a Creative Commons License
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/ie/
File(s)
Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Name

InsidersOutsiders.pdf

Description
Original submission
Size

3.03 MB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum (MD5)

51ac3e5f7dc966ec09d9329139101dcd

Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Name

InsidersOutsidersandtheGeographyofRegionalLife.pdf

Description
Secondary copy
Size

8.26 MB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum (MD5)

4b069314099e4dc5b72969508be36684

Owning collection
Geography Research Collection

Item descriptive metadata is released under a CC-0 (public domain) license: https://creativecommons.org/public-domain/cc0/.
All other content is subject to copyright.

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science

  • Cookie settings
  • Privacy policy
  • End User Agreement