Options
On Sellars' exam question trilemma: are Kant's premises analytic, or synthetic a priori, or a posteriori?
Author(s)
Date Issued
2019-03-04
Date Available
2021-08-13T11:36:03Z
Abstract
Wilfrid Sellars argued that Kant’s account of the conceptual structures involved in experience can be given a linguistic turn so as to provide an analytic account of the resources a language must have in order to be the bearer of empirical knowledge. In this paper I examine the methodological aspects of Kant’s transcendental philosophy that Sellars took to be fundamental to influential themes in his own philosophy. My first aim here is to clarify and argue for the plausibility of what I claim is Sellars’ interpretation of Kant’s ‘analytic’ transcendental method in the first Critique, based ultimately on non-trivial analytic truths concerning the concept of an object of our possible experience. Kant’s ‘transcendental proofs’ thereby avoid a certain methodological trilemma confronting the candidate premises of any such proof, taken from Sellars’ 1970s undergraduate exam question on Kant. In part II of the essay I conclude by highlighting in general terms how Kant’s method, as interpreted in the analytic manner explained in part I, was adapted by Sellars to produce some of the more influential aspects of his own philosophy, expressed in terms of what he contends is their sustainable reformulation in light of the so-called linguistic turn in twentieth-century philosophy.
Type of Material
Journal Article
Publisher
Taylor & Francis
Journal
British Journal for the History of Philosophy
Volume
27
Issue
2
Start Page
402
End Page
421
Copyright (Published Version)
2018 British Society for the History of Philosophy
Language
English
Status of Item
Peer reviewed
ISSN
0960-8788
This item is made available under a Creative Commons License
File(s)
Loading...
Name
O'Shea, James (2019) 'Sellars' Exam Question Trilemma - Are Kant's Premises Analytic, or Sythetic A Priori, or A Posteriori' (in Brit.J.Hist.Phil).pdf
Size
285.94 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
6b169215d95795e6ada7f85452fa7955
Owning collection