Acting against your better judgement
Files in This Item:
|Acting against your better judgement preprint.docx||56.33 kB||Unknown||Request a copy|
|Title:||Acting against your better judgement||Authors:||Stout, Rowland||Editors:||Yang, Syrara C-M||Permanent link:||http://hdl.handle.net/10197/11261||Date:||1-Apr-2020||Online since:||2020-02-07T16:29:07Z||Abstract:||I defend a Davidsonian approach to weakness of will against some recent arguments by John McDowell, and adapt the approach to meet other objections. Instead of treating one’s better judgement as a conditional judgement about what is desirable to do given available reasons, it is proposed to treat it as an unconditional judgement about what is desirable to do from a rational perspective that one takes to be the right perspective to have. This makes sense of Aristotle’s claim that desire is for the good or the apparent good: judgements of desirability generally concern the apparent good, whereas judgements of desirability from rational perspectives that are judged to be the ones to have are judgements of the actual good. Weakness of will occurs when one’s actual rational perspective is not the one that one takes to be the one to have - i.e. when one’s judgement of the apparent good does not coincide with one’s judgement of the actual good. One makes two judgements – one from an adopted perspective that one judges to be the one to have and one from one’s actual perspective.||Type of material:||Book Chapter||Publisher:||Springer||Keywords:||Intentional action; Weakness of will; Motivation; Adopting perspectives||Language:||en||Status of Item:||Peer reviewed||Is part of:||Yang SC-M. (eds.). Davidson's Philosophy of Mind and Action|
|Appears in Collections:||Philosophy Research Collection|
Show full item record
This item is available under the Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Ireland. No item may be reproduced for commercial purposes. For other possible restrictions on use please refer to the publisher's URL where this is made available, or to notes contained in the item itself. Other terms may apply.