Variance and accuracy in probability estimation from samples : the case of cognitive biases
Files in This Item:
|1765311.pdf||1.71 MB||Adobe PDF||Request a copy|
|Title:||Variance and accuracy in probability estimation from samples : the case of cognitive biases||Authors:||Howe, Rita||Permanent link:||http://hdl.handle.net/10197/11657||Date:||2020||Online since:||2020-11-04T05:34:40Z||Abstract:||A number of recent theories have suggested that the various systematic biases and fallacies seen in people's probabilistic reasoning may arise purely as a consequence of random variation in the reasoning process. The underlying argument, in these theories, is that random variation has systematic regressive effects, so producing the observed patterns of bias. These theories typically take this random variation as a given, and assume that the degree of random variation in probabilistic reasoning is sufficiently large to account for observed patterns of fallacy and bias; there has been very little research directly examining the character of random variation in people's probabilistic judgement. In this thesis, 4 experiments are described that investigate the degree, level, and characteristic properties of random variation in people's probability judgement. They show that the degree of variance is easily large enough to account for the occurrence of two central fallacies in probabilistic reasoning (the conjunction fallacy and the disjunction fallacy), and that level of variance is a reliable predictor of the occurrence of these fallacies. In addition, it is demonstrated that random variance in people's probabilistic judgement follows a particular mathematical model from frequentist probability theory: the binomial proportion distribution. This result supports a model in which people reason about probabilities in a way that follows frequentist probability theory but is subject to random variation or noise.||Type of material:||Doctoral Thesis||Publisher:||University College Dublin. School of Computer Science||Qualification Name:||Ph.D.||Copyright (published version):||2020 the Author||Keywords:||Probability estimation; Variance; Cognitive bias||Language:||en||Status of Item:||Peer reviewed|
|Appears in Collections:||Computer Science Theses|
Show full item record
This item is available under the Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Ireland. No item may be reproduced for commercial purposes. For other possible restrictions on use please refer to the publisher's URL where this is made available, or to notes contained in the item itself. Other terms may apply.