De Generatione et Corruptione 2.3: Does Aristotle Identify the Contraries as Elements?

Files in This Item:
File Description SizeFormat 
GC_2.3.pdf179.43 kBAdobe PDFDownload
Title: De Generatione et Corruptione 2.3: Does Aristotle Identify the Contraries as Elements?
Authors: Crowley, Timothy J.
Permanent link:
Date: May-2013
Online since: 2014-10-22T13:40:13Z
Abstract: It might seem quite commonplace to say that Aristotle identifies fire, air, water and earth as the στοιχεῖα, or ‘elements’ – or, to be more precise, as the elements of bodies that are subject to generation and corruption. Yet there is a tradition of interpretation, already evident in the work of the sixth-century commentator John Philoponus and widespread, indeed prevalent, today, according to which Aristotle does not really believe that fire, air, water and earth are truly elemental. The basic premise of this interpretation is that Aristotle takes fire, air, water and earth to be, in some sense, composite bodies and, as such, analysable into simpler constituents. But, of course, an element of bodies is defined by Aristotle himself as something into which bodies can be analysed, and which does not admit further analysis (Metaph. 5.3, 1014a26–1014b15; Cael. 3.3, 302a14–21). So if fire, air, water and earth can be analysed into simpler or more basic constituents, then it would seem to follow that the latter ought to be considered Aristotle's true elements. These are usually identified as the primary contraries hot and cold, dry and wet; many, perhaps most, commentators would insist also upon prime matter as the subject upon which these contraries act.
Type of material: Journal Article
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
Journal: Classical Quarterly
Volume: 63
Issue: 1
Start page: 161
End page: 182
Copyright (published version): 2013 The Classical Association
Keywords: Four elements (Philosophy)Stoicheia
DOI: 10.1017/S0009838812000584
Language: en
Status of Item: Peer reviewed
Appears in Collections:Philosophy Research Collection

Show full item record

Citations 50

Last Week
Last month
checked on Feb 12, 2019

Google ScholarTM



This item is available under the Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Ireland. No item may be reproduced for commercial purposes. For other possible restrictions on use please refer to the publisher's URL where this is made available, or to notes contained in the item itself. Other terms may apply.