Urban Institute Ireland Research Collection

This study investigated an important issue of aluminium (Al) release in a novel reuse of Al-based water treatment sludge (Al-WTS) in constructed wetland system (CWs) as alternative substrate for wastewater treatment. Al-WTS is an inevitable by-product of drinking water treatment plants that use Al-salt as coagulant for raw water purification. It has recently been demonstrated that Al-WTS can be reused as a low-cost phosphorus (P) adsorbent and biofilm carrier in CWs for wastewater treatment. However, to facilitate the large scale application of Al-WTS in CWs as wetland substrate, concerns about Al leaching during its’ reuse in CWs must be addressed as Al is a dominant constituent in Al-WTS. In this study, a desk review of literature on Al release during Al-WTS reuse was conducted. Furthermore, a 42-week Al monitoring was carried out on a pilot field-scale CWs employing Al-WTS as main substrate. Results show that 22 out of the 35 studies reviewed, reported Al release with levels of soluble Al reported ranging from 0.01 to about 20 mg L-1. Monitoring of Al in the pilot field-scale CWs shows that there was Al leaching. However, except for the first three weeks of operation, effluents concentrations of both total- and soluble-Al were all below the general regulatory guideline limit of 0.2 mg L-1. Overall, the study addresses a very vital concern regarding the successful application of Al-WTS in CWs and shows that Al release during such novel reuse is quite low and should not preclude its use.

Drinking-water treatment sludge (DWTS) produced at water treatment plants is an inescapable by-product and has long been treated as a waste for landfill. In this study, a series of batch adsorption tests were conducted using a wide range of phosphorus (P) species to determine the adsorption capacities of freshly dewatered aluminium salt based DWTS. The adsorption process is highly dependant on the pH of the suspension and is good at low pHs with adsorption capacities in the order of orthophosphate>polyphosphate>organic phosphate when these three P species were simulated according to their level in typical municipal wastewater. At pH 4.0, the adsorption capacity for orthophosphate was 10.2 mg-PO43-/g DWTS, polyphosphate was 7.4 mg-PO43-/g DWTS and organic phosphate was 4.8 mg-PO43-/g DWTS. Subsequently, a continuous flow column test with dewatered Al-based DWTS as filter medium was conducted at a hydraulic loading of 2.79 m3/m2.d and an extremely high P loading of 210.5 PO43-/m2.d. The sludge bed remained stable and removed over 80% P in a 30 day period and the bed did not reach saturation point for over 60 days. This proves the potential of the sludge as a filter material in various forms of P immobilization, thus converting it from a waste to a useful material in pollutant control.

Waterworks sludge continues to be an inescapable by-product of the potable water treatment process. Accordingly, final disposal of the sludge remains one of the most significant pressing problems for the potable water treatment industry. The possibility of reusing the sludge as a main substrate in a novel constructed wetland system was investigated in this study. Results show that significant phosphorus (P) and other pollutants removal were achieved in the system. With a mean influent BOD5 (5-day biochemical oxygen demand) and COD (chemical oxygen demand) levels of 392.7 mg/l and 579.8 mg/l, respectively, a removal efficiency of 90.6 % and 71.8 %, respectively, was obtained. P removal was however exceptionally high despite the high influent mean P level of 45.3 mg-P/l, which is about 2-3 times the level of P commonly found in sewage. This is attributable to the P adsorption capacity of the alum sludge and this highlights the benefits of its reuse in the system. The paper presents and discusses the findings from a laboratory scale research, which has potential for further large scale implementation.

The adsorption equilibrium of a wide range of phosphorus species by an aluminium-based water treatment sludge (Al-WTS) was examined in this study. Four kinds of adsorption-isotherm models, namely Langmuir, Freundlich, Temkin and Dubinin-Radushkevich, were used to fit the adsorption equilibrium data. In order to optimise the adsorption-isotherm model, correlation coefficient (R2) and four error functions were employed to facilitate the evaluation of fitting accuracy. Experiments have demonstrated that the Al-WTS may be an excellent raw material to adsorb P in polluted aqueous environment with adsorption ability in the order of KH2PO4 (ortho-P) > Na(PO3)6 (poly-P) > C10H14N5O7P·H2O (organic-P). More importantly, this study provides an entire comparison of the four isotherms in describing the P adsorption behaviour. By considering both the standard least-square based R2 and the results of four error functions analysis, this study reveals that the Freundlich isotherm appears to be the best model to fit the experimental equilibrium data. Langmuir and Temkin isotherms are also good models in current experimental conditions while Dubinin-Radushkevich isotherm poorly described the adsorption behaviour. The error analysis in this study provides vital evidence to reflect its role in facilitating the optimisation in adsorption isotherm study. Obviously, R2 seems inadequate in optimising multi-isotherm models due to its inherent bias resulting from the least-squares linearisation.